November 16, 2026
Shay & Izzy's Fall Engagement Session in New Paltz, NY
- Engagement Sessions
Shay and Izzy matched on Tinder while Izzy was visiting New York from college in Georgia, where they sang in a chamber choir that once performed at Carnegie Hall. The two missed meeting each other in person on that trip, but kept talking anyway. Six months of nonstop conversation later, and they finally met in person in Georgia. Eventually, Izzy made the move up to New York to be with Shay, and the two now live together in Kingston. Shay proposed on a picnic near Peekskill, box of cheesecake included, with a friend there to photograph the moment.
By the time I met them for their engagement session, they had just celebrated three years together and were planning their wedding next October at the Garrison. Casual and a little silly is exactly how they described themselves, and it's exactly the energy we built the whole session around.
The original plan was Mohonk Preserve, but we found out last minute that Mohonk requires a photography permit for sessions like this one, which meant pivoting on the spot. Luckily, Shay is a grad student at SUNY New Paltz, and he knew exactly where to go instead: the campus pond, just a few minutes from where we'd originally planned to shoot.
It turned out to be the better call anyway. Shay and Izzy coordinated without being matchy: Izzy in a white quarter-zip, khakis, a beige beanie, and white sneakers, and Shay in a brown and black sweater under a brown leather jacket, dark jeans, brown boots, and a dark brown beanie. All the earthy tones played well against the water and the turning autumn leaves. Since it was a Sunday, the campus was quiet, a fraction of the foot traffic you'd see on a weekday, which gave us plenty of space along the pond to work with the light and the backdrop.
I'd spotted Apple Hill Farm on the drive over and wanted to make a stop before we finished the session. We got there close to closing time, which meant we had the place almost entirely to ourselves. Right at the base of the orchard was a display of pumpkins and hay bales for one set of photos, and then we moved to an open field in front of the orchard for another. Even though they were wearing the same outfits, the orchard provided a different feel, and it was a good reminder that a quick, unplanned detour can end up being one of the best parts of a session.
New Paltz is hard to beat for fall color, whichever direction you point the camera. If Mohonk Preserve is on your list, plan ahead and confirm their photography permit requirements before you build a timeline around it (we learned that one in real time). The SUNY New Paltz campus is a quieter, free alternative with real character, especially on a weekend. And if a session like this one only scratches the surface for you, downtown New Paltz is worth considering too, it offers a completely different look built around architecture and small-town character rather than open scenery.
Shay and Izzy were some of the warmest, most affectionate people I've photographed. You can feel it in how they move together, and I can't wait for their wedding at the Garrison next fall!
I'm a wedding and engagement photographer based in Westchester County, working with couples across NYC, the Hudson Valley, and Fairfield County. Reach out through my contact form to talk through locations, timing, and what to wear.